Top 5 Worst National Champions in College Football History

Not every team that wins a national championship is remembered as dominant. Sometimes the title comes with controversy, sometimes it is shared, and sometimes it feels undeserved altogether. History has crowned champions who were not universally regarded as the best, and in hindsight, their flaws stand out even more. Here are five of the weakest national champions in college football history.

1984 BYU Cougars

BYU claimed its first and only national title by beating unranked Michigan 24–17 in the Holiday Bowl. The Cougars went undefeated, but their schedule left plenty to be desired. They faced just one ranked opponent, Pittsburgh, and the Panthers quickly fell out of the polls on their way to a 3–7–1 season. Only two of BYU’s opponents finished with more than seven wins. The Cougars were voted No. 1 in both the AP and coaches’ polls because they were the only undefeated team, but the lack of quality wins makes this one of the most questionable championships ever awarded.

2003 LSU Tigers

LSU shared its championship with USC, which finished No. 1 in the AP poll. The Tigers went 13–1, their lone stumble a 19–7 loss to unranked Florida. They recovered to win the SEC and defeated Oklahoma in the BCS title game, but many fans and analysts argued that USC was the rightful champion. The Trojans ended 14–1 with a dominant Rose Bowl win over No. 4 Michigan and held the top spot in both the AP and coaches’ polls before the BCS computers inserted Oklahoma into the title game. LSU took advantage of that break, but the split title left plenty of debate.

1990 Colorado Buffaloes

Colorado finished 11–1–1 and claimed the AP title, while Georgia Tech took the coaches’ crown. The Buffaloes’ season was defined as much by controversy as by wins. In one of the most infamous moments in college football history, officials awarded Colorado a fifth down against Missouri, a mistake that allowed the Buffaloes to score the game-winning touchdown. Their résumé also included a loss to Illinois and a tie with Tennessee. For a team remembered more for a referee blunder than its dominance, this title remains one of the sport’s most tainted.

1997 Michigan Wolverines

Michigan went 12–0 and finished No. 1 in the AP poll after winning the Rose Bowl, but Nebraska also went undefeated and claimed the coaches’ poll title. Nebraska’s case was strengthened by its 42–17 rout of No. 3 Tennessee in the Orange Bowl, a game designated as the national championship under the Bowl Alliance system. Michigan still claims its share of the title, but the split left fans debating which team truly deserved to be called the best.

2007 LSU Tigers

The 2007 season was defined by chaos, and LSU was the biggest beneficiary. The Tigers went 10–2 in the regular season, losing to 7–5 Kentucky and 8–4 Arkansas, both in triple overtime. They rallied to win the SEC and beat Ohio State in the BCS title game, becoming one of only three teams ever to win a national championship with two losses, joining 1960 Minnesota and 2025 Ohio State. While LSU took home the trophy, few would argue that this was a great team.

Parting Shot

National championships are supposed to define greatness, but history shows that is not always the case. BYU’s soft schedule, Colorado’s controversial finish, and LSU’s chaotic run in 2007 all illustrate how timing, luck, and flawed systems have shaped the sport’s history. These teams own the hardware, but they are remembered as much for their imperfections as their titles.

Want more Sandman? Come connect with us here at sandmansports.com/onestopshop